A LETTER FROM A READER - MARY JANES
A LETTER FROM A READER
I thought Mary Janes belonged in my past. Then I pictured this pair with the clothes I wear now.
I have a row of perfectly sensible shoes by the door. Black sneakers, practical flats, a pair I keep meaning to replace. They do their job. But somewhere along the way, I stopped choosing shoes because I liked the way they finished an outfit.
Mary Janes had become something I remembered, rather than something I pictured wearing now. Then I saw the Sophie buckle shoes in Eloise New York’s collection, and found myself looking twice.
I wanted a pair I would choose before I reached for the same old shoes.
It started with the strap
The shape was familiar, but the combination caught my attention: a dark toe, a patterned upper, and that neat buckle. I could picture them under the black ankle pants already hanging in my closet.
I looked through the collection before settling on Sophie. There were simpler straps, T-straps, and different heel shapes. This was the pair I kept returning to.
Different straps, silhouettes, and colors in one collection
The outfit didn’t need changing
In the mirror, I imagined my usual ivory blouse and black pants, with the hem high enough to show the strap. The shoes gave that familiar combination a different finish.
For me, that is the appeal: starting with clothes I already know how to wear.
Three details I would look at first
One. The shape of the toe. Sophie’s contrasting front draws the eye without needing a bright color.
Two. The strap and buckle. I would leave a little space between my pant hem and the shoe so the detail remains visible.
Three. The right size. Before ordering, I would compare the product’s size guide with my measurements. A photograph can show the style; it cannot tell me how a shoe will fit my foot.
About the price
Sophie is currently listed at $109.95, with a comparison price of $200.00 and a 45% discount badge in the store. Prices differ across the collection: Leni is $69.95, while Greta is $59.95.
Anniversary sale: up to 70% off
Across the online store, with extra savings when you buy more items.
Current offer and eligibility are subject to the store’s terms. Check your order total at checkout.
I would choose the pair I actually want to wear, then check the selected size and final total. The extra savings are useful when there is another item on the list already.
The detail I kept coming back to
The buckle and contrasting toe are what caught my eye. I would wear this pair with cropped pants so the shape really shows.
See two more reviews
Easy to picture in my wardrobe
I can picture these with a simple skirt and cardigan. I would check the size chart before choosing my pair.
Something a little different
The vintage shape is what I like. The two-tone look gives a plain outfit a point of interest.
What I’d tell you over coffee
If your shoes have become the part of getting dressed you never think about, try picturing a different pair with an outfit you already own. For me, it would be Sophie with ankle pants and a plain blouse.
Start with the shape you like. Then take your time with the sizing.
Susan
Sophie – Vintage Buckle Shoes
$200.00$109.95Save 45%
- Vintage buckle silhouette
- Contrasting toe and patterned upper
- Listed in black and brown
- Sizes 5–10 listed; check the size guide
- Pair with skirts, dresses, or ankle pants
Current sizes and details on the product page
More styles from the same collection
−67%Leni – Timeless Strap Shoes
−70%Greta – Classic Leather T-Strap Shoes with Braided Detail
−50%Hannah – Buckle Shoes
−69%Ella – Mid-Heel Shoes
−70%Clara – Elegant Mary Jane Shoes
−51%Leonie – Mary Jane Shoes